Have you ever heard of the 1973 movie “Scarecrow”? No? Well, don’t feel bad; it’s one of those forgotten classics that didn’t do well at the box office despite starring Gene Hackman and Al Pacino. “Scarecrow,” directed by Jerry Schatzberg, is a poignant and introspective road movie featuring two of the biggest stars of the day in two of their most compelling roles. The film is an exploration of friendship, disillusionment, and the quest for meaning in the lives of two drifters. It is a piece of cinema that quietly resonates with its audience through its character-driven narrative and the magnetic performances of its leads.
The story centers on Max Millan (Gene Hackman), a gruff and bitter ex-convict with dreams of opening a car wash in Pittsburgh, and Francis Lionel “Lion” Delbuchi (Al Pacino), a quirky and optimistic former sailor. They meet by chance while hitchhiking and quickly form an unlikely and often uneasy partnership. Max is hard-edged and cynical, a man whose years in prison have left him distrustful and hardened. In contrast, Lion is almost childlike in his innocence and whimsical outlook on life. He believes that laughter is the key to disarming people and navigating the world, a belief symbolized by his “scarecrow” theory — that a scarecrow isn’t frightening, but rather, it is funny and therefore, non-threatening.
The film’s strength lies in its character development and the dynamic between Max and Lion. Hackman and Pacino deliver masterful performances that bring depth and authenticity to their characters. Hackman portrays Max with a simmering intensity, a man constantly on the edge, whose dream of a car wash represents his desperate need for stability and purpose. Pacino, on the other hand, infuses Lion with a disarming charm and a sense of vulnerability. His portrayal of Lion is tender and heart-wrenching, particularly as his past and his reasons for drifting come to light.
Jerry Schatzberg’s direction is understated yet effective, allowing the characters and their journey to take center stage. The cinematography, with its emphasis on the vast and often desolate American landscape, underscores the themes of isolation and the search for belonging. The film avoids melodrama, instead opting for a realistic portrayal of two men trying to make sense of their lives in a world that often seems indifferent to their existence.
“Scarecrow” is not a plot-driven movie; rather, it is a character study and a meditation on the human condition. The episodic structure of the film, with Max and Lion encountering various people and situations, serves to highlight their contrasting worldviews and deepen their bond. There are moments of humor, pathos, and tension, each contributing to the gradual unraveling of their characters.
One of the most powerful aspects of the film is its exploration of the theme of disillusionment. Both Max and Lion are dreamers in their own ways, but harsh realities continuously thwart their dreams. Max’s dream of a car wash is a symbol of his desire for a normal life, yet his abrasive nature and past experiences make it a distant goal. Lion’s journey to reunite with his estranged wife and child reveals the deep wounds of abandonment and the fragile nature of his optimism.
The film’s climax is both devastating and inevitable, a testament to the unpredictability of life and the resilience of the human spirit. The final scenes, where the characters’ dreams and hopes are brought to a shattering confrontation with reality, leave a lasting impact on the viewer. It serves as a sobering reminder of the fragility of human aspirations and the often cruel twists of fate.
“Scarecrow” was not a commercial success upon its release, possibly due to its melancholic tone and unconventional narrative structure. However, it has since gained recognition as a classic of 1970s American cinema, appreciated for its emotional depth and the remarkable performances of its lead actors. The film won the Grand Prix at the 1973 Cannes Film Festival, a testament to its artistic merit and the profound impact it had on those who appreciated its quiet power.
“Scarecrow” is a film that lingers in the mind long after the credits roll. It is a beautifully crafted exploration of friendship, dreams, and the human condition, brought to life by the extraordinary talents of Gene Hackman and Al Pacino. Jerry Schatzberg’s direction and the film’s evocative cinematography create a compelling portrait of two lost souls navigating the harsh landscapes of America and their own personal struggles. “Scarecrow” is a timeless piece of cinema that continues to resonate with audiences, offering a poignant and unflinching look at the complexities of life and the bonds that sustain us through its challenges. It’s available in a variety of formats and I highly recommend it.
John Berkovich Talks 